Skip to content
Email basics November 4, 2026 · 3 min read · By Smailor Team

Also in FrançaisEspañolDeutsch

Email sender reputation: what it is and how it works

Sender reputation is the score a mailbox provider keeps about who sends mail to its users. There is no single number and nothing you can buy: Gmail, Microsoft and Yahoo each compute their own from what they observe. When two senders write the same message, reputation is the reason one reaches the inbox and the other reaches spam.

IP reputation and domain reputation

IP reputation follows the server's address. Domain reputation follows your domain, read from the signature of your DKIM and the From line.

The balance has moved towards the domain, because the domain is what stays with you. Changing provider gives you a new IP, while your domain's history comes along. Conversely, on a shared IP other customers can affect your results, though large providers keep those pools under watch.

What moves the score

Lowers it Raises it
Recipients clicking "report spam" Replies
Hard bounces from dead addresses Moving mail from spam to inbox
Addresses that are spam traps Adding you to contacts
Sudden jumps in volume Steady, predictable volume
Failing SPF, DKIM or DMARC Authentication that passes every time
Being on a blacklist Recipients who open and read

Complaints count most. Gmail's guidance for bulk senders is to stay under 0.3% and aim for under 0.1%. That means one complaint per thousand messages is already close to the line.

Spam traps deserve a word. They are addresses that never signed up for anything, or old abandoned ones reused to catch senders with stale lists. A single hit can matter, and you only get them from purchased or very old lists.

How to see your reputation

  • Google Postmaster Tools. Free. Add your domain and read spam rate, authentication results and delivery errors for mail to Gmail. It needs some volume before showing data.
  • Microsoft SNDS. Free. Shows IP data for mail to Outlook and Hotmail, if you control the IP.
  • Blacklist lookups for your IP and your domain.
  • Your own headers, by sending to yourself on each provider and reading the result.

If you run under a few hundred messages a day, these tools may show little. Your bounces and replies are then your best signal.

How to repair it

  1. Find the cause: a list, a tool, a compromised account. An account sending spam after a stolen password is a common and sudden reason.
  2. Stop the bad mail first. Nothing else helps until it stops.
  3. Clean the list and remove anyone who has not engaged for months.
  4. Restart slowly with your most engaged recipients, as in a warm-up.
  5. Expect weeks. The score follows sustained behaviour, and no request speeds it up.

Frequently asked questions

Does a new domain have a bad reputation?

It has none, which filters treat with caution. Very new domains are often filtered harder for their first weeks. Start small with real conversations.

Can I check it with a single score?

Commercial tools offer one, but they estimate. Providers do not publish theirs. Trust Postmaster data and real replies over any single number.

Is it worth using a subdomain for newsletters?

Yes. Sending bulk mail from news.example.com keeps part of the risk away from your main domain. It does not protect you fully, since the parent domain also carries weight.

Does one spam report matter?

Rarely on its own. It is the rate over time that counts.

On Smailor, the delivery statistics show how the mail of your own domain is doing.